Are The LOTR Books Better Than The Movies?

Which is better LOTR or Harry Potter?

Harry Potter has much more rounded and relatable characters and (I would argue) better storytelling than LOTR, but LOTR is way better at world-building and lore.

The Harry Potter series does character development beautifully..

Who is better Dumbledore or Gandalf?

Gandalf is greater than Dumbledore although (or perhaps because) he had less power. He rallied all the free peoples of Middle-Earth to the cause, gave them heart, and sacrificed himself to save his friends and the quest in Moria. He worked tirelessly for centuries.

How accurate are the LOTR movies?

As movie adaptations tend to go, they are not wildly unfaithful. If you look at the “big picture”, it is about 80 % the “same” story. But if you try to zoom in on the details, there are very few (if any) scenes that play out detail by detail and line by line just as in the book.

Is the Lord of the Rings the best trilogy ever?

The trilogy as a whole is very good, and would probably be in my top fifty. … It is definitely the best recent trilogy though. It is a lot better than say, the Harry Potter franchise or the Nolan batman movies. It is not the best trilogy ever, being beaten by the Dollars Trilogy, original Star Wars and the Godfather.

Why are the Lord of the Rings movies so good?

Lord the Rings gave us Harry Potter, Star Wars, Game of Thrones, and every other major franchise. It was the original good vs evil story. The story doesn’t seem so impressive now because it’s style and themes were copied so many times before the films came out. … Maybe the films did bore you.

What can books do that movies can t?

5 Things Books Can Do That Movies Can’tPrinted words have a power of their own.Books have the power to completely transport you to another world.You are in control of what you see.You get insight into a character’s internal monologue.They don’t have to necessarily be romance heavy.

Should I read Hobbit or LOTR first?

You should be fine either way. You don’t need to have read The Hobbit to understand the LotR, though there are many references to Bilbo’s journey in the trilogy. There are many fine versions of The Hobbit. The text itself should be pretty much the same in any edition.

Is Lord of the Rings older than Harry Potter?

For the record, J.R.R. Tolkien published “The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring” in 1954. (“The Hobbit” was published several years earlier in 1937.) The first Harry Potter book, “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone” came out in 1997.

Will there be another Lord of the Rings trilogy?

Lord of the Rings was set in the Third Age, and this series will take place in The Second Age, Amazon revealed in a tweet sent in March 2019. … Amazon’s Salke told Deadline, “we’re not remaking the movies, but we’re also not starting from scratch. So, it’ll be characters you love.”

Why are the movies better than books?

Watching a motion picture is an inherently more passive experience than reading a book. Yet it imparts content in a much more easily consumable way than a book of commensurate length. Movies are more tangible, visual, and compact than comparable written works, and are therefore easier to remember.

What is the best LOTR book?

There And Back Again: The Top J.R.R. Tolkien Books, RankedBilbo’s Last Song. … The Children of Hurin. … The Shaping of Middle-Earth: The Quenta, the Ambarkanta, and the Annals, Together With the Earliest ‘Silmarillion’ and the First Map (History of Middle-earth)

Is Lord of the Rings a hard read?

The stories, characters, and world can be hard to conceptualize for young readers, but the actual language is not incredibly difficult. I do think someone who is very comfortable with English will appreciate the delicate word choice and rhythm of the books, but you shouldn’t have any trouble understanding them.

Is Lord of the Rings like Harry Potter?

Harry Potter takes place in about the late ’90s in the UK, while Lord of the Rings takes place in about the 3000s in Middle-earth. Therefore, while some of the characters look similar, it would be pretty hard for them to be related. The first one is the obvious one, Dumbledore and Gandalf.

What is the best trilogy ever?

Top 10 movie trilogies of all time: Lord of the Rings, Star Wars, The Godfather and moreThe Lord of the Rings: Netflix and Amazon Prime Video. … Star Wars: Disney+ Hotstar. … The Godfather: Amazon Prime Video. … Before trilogy: Netflix. … Toy Story: Disney+ Hotstar. … The Dark Knight trilogy: Netflix and Amazon Prime Video.More items…•

Why Lord of the Rings should be banned?

The classic trilogy, along with The Hobbit, has been banned in many schools and public libraries across the nation. … According to a National Health Service anti-smoking group in Plymouth, England, children should be banned from watching films like Lord of the Rings because they feature people smoking.

Is watching better than reading?

Reading is an active process whereas watching is a passive one. One needs a lot more attention while reading a book than that of watching videos. That is the reason for slowness in the process of reading. … Learning highly complex things is much faster and easier with videos as compared to the books.

Why is watching movies bad for you?

“Very intense movies do increase heart rate, and if you have coronary heart disease, (they) can increase chest pain and blood pressure,” Bakris said. Know before you go: Watching a horror movie can cause a spike in adrenaline and cortisol levels.

Is LOTR worth reading?

The Lord of the Rings trilogy is absolutely worth reading, even though they’re very long and a bit monotonous. There’s so much to the story that doesn’t make it into movies, side stories and fascinating tidbits that you miss if you don’t take the plunge.